Your paper, with its data. The agent finds the biggest problem and tries to fix it, while we do something else.
You know the field. The agent does the reading; you do the judging.
It will want to run code. If it stops to ask, it waits for you while you’re away.
Take this paper apart, like a tough methods referee who also has the data. Run the analysis yourself and check that the numbers in the draft match the code. If there is a preregistration, compare the paper with it. Find the single biggest problem, then propose a fix and show what changes. Write everything to take-apart.md. Work on your own; I’ll be back in 20 minutes.
Then leave it. Next: It wants to please you.
Read take-apart.md. Then push:
Interviews, not data? “Which claims rest on the fewest interviews?” “What else would explain the same quotes?”
Next: the blind referee panel.